36 Comments
Jan 18Liked by Etana Hecht

May his memory be a blessing.

Thank you so much for your insightful, loving writings. As a Christian my heart breaks for what you all are going through, and I pray daily for the peace of Jerusalem and the peace of Israel. God bless you.

Expand full comment
Jan 19Liked by Etana Hecht

I'm surprised how few people recognize that Iran is using Hamas to do its dirty work. And the Jew bashing is nauseating. You'd think people would remember what happened to the last guy who thought he could eradicate the Jews.

Expand full comment
Jan 18Liked by Etana Hecht

Will be 73 soon, I became a christian in 1983, understood then and now that Israel is forever. God bless you

Expand full comment

❤️עם ישראל חי

Expand full comment
Jan 18Liked by Etana Hecht

Thank you Etana, for your beautiful words. From one Elisha to another Elisha, I will contribute.

Expand full comment
Jan 20·edited Jan 20Liked by Etana Hecht

I feel the same as you about living in Israel. The problem is when people make aliya and don't have the faith (faithfulness) to adapt to the changes and patiently put down roots -- they return to their old home after a few years and blame the failure on everything except themselves.

After 40 years of seeing this trend, I've stopped trying to talk people into it. Especially American Jews. The spark of desire will come from GOD (as it did for you, and for me) or not at all.

But don't worry, Etana. He will finish what He started.

"Then they will know that I am the LORD their GOD because I made them go into exile among the nations, and then I gathered them again to their own land; and **I will leave none of them there any longer**. (Ezek. 39)

Expand full comment
Jan 18Liked by Etana Hecht

Thank you for this beautiful and thoughtful piece. Exactly what I needed to hear.

Btw, I love the misspelling of “desert” as “dessert!”

Expand full comment
Jan 19Liked by Etana Hecht

The blind perversity is other Worldly.

Thankfully, the masks are off for All To See.

Expand full comment

You want some time for honesty. Read some history. This started in the early 1900s and the slaughter and removal of over 750,000 Palestinians in 1948. How did it feel to look out that lovely view and know that it was stolen from the indigenous people there for hundreds and hundreds years? Blood on your hands. Save your pity party, from another Jew who knows her history.

Expand full comment

OUTSTANDING -- timely and noble. Gazans are dying and starving en masse – they should be in East Jerusalem and West Bank from where they have been ethnically cleansed - Jan 2024

https://rumble.com/v47psrk-terrible-slaughter-underway-in-gaza-south-african-foreign-minister.html

‘Terrible slaughter underway in Gaza’ – South African foreign minister

Expand full comment

these are not the really tough questions, Etana.

Expand full comment

I am a US born Gentile Messianic Christian and believe that God is calling the Jews back to Israel. Persecution and the possible coming civil war and unrest will be the most likely scenarios for the Jews to leave the US and return to Israel.

Expand full comment

I just discovered that Israel did 9/11:

https://binkylarue.substack.com/p/israel-and-elements-of-the-us-government

I used to cheer Israel on, saw the country as a bastion of freedom in a land of oppression and darkness. I have changed my mind.

Expand full comment

People hate the Jews because they hate God and themselves.

Expand full comment